Posted in progress

Something I Realised Earlier

Whilst having a read of some other bloggers material I found myself responding to an article saying I can only really write silly stories or comedy, basically anything aimed at children.  If you ask me to try and write a 2000 word story on Action or Romance I’d fall down flat by the end of the first sentence.

I’ve always been like this.  At University I wrote a script which I now recoil in horror at the thought of as the theme was Sci-Fi drama.  I was really into the TV show ‘Heroes’ at the time and wanted to write a story where this girl had to go and uncover all these truths about her past and her present, unless I go delving into the NAS drive and pick out the script, I don’t recall how it ended BUT I do remember the feeling of just wanting the stupid story finished because I hated it! The Uni module was a DIY one, you set your own assignments, deadlines, progress and present it at the end and I quite enjoyed that freedom and creativity of setting personal deadlines.

This Sci-Fi drama I wrote was actually a second choice to the whole module.  First choice came easily to me, the class loved the pitch, the new stand-in tutor, not so much, people wondered where I got the idea from but I had it properly plotted out, first draft done etc. So what stopped me going down this route? My gut instinct.  It was telling me it was too silly an idea added with the disapproval from the new industry professional tutor I just backed out.

I shall tell you the idea since I have no passion to ever go back to it.  It was a world all about gnomes.  It’d be a dark comedy, just saying that now in case you think it’s something maybe Cbeebies could pick up, no it really isn’t at all.  The gnomes co-existed quite contently with cats. The cats didn’t speak but they had a mutual connection, it was them versus the humans – both live in parallel.  There was this really corrupt gnome who goes on the rampage to try and upset his world because he hated it so much, he goes as far to damage the connection they have with cats and it is the wife of this psychotic gnome who we actually root for, it is all about her rising up against her husband and helping the community to stay as one. I don’t know where the idea came from but I always seemed to have them fully formed as soon as a new assignment came in, weird right?

I spent 2 years working on various scripts and I realise I purposely avoided themes that were serious or too close to real life and instead went to the other end of the spectrum but found it really fun.  I wonder if the writer in me SHOULD consider other themes in the future.  Double check my forte as they say.

What do you think? should a writer have multiple styles/methods of writing even if gut instinct says play to your strengths? What if you don’t know your own strengths yet?




"I loved writing as a child, loved making up silly stories. They came built-in to my brain, almost like an Ikea instruction manual. The focus these days is to figure out how to now turn them into books" Tanya Butler, June 2018

2 thoughts on “Something I Realised Earlier

  1. To answer the question properly, see Pratchett and the Discworld series. He tried other writing types (e.g. with Neil Gaiman et al) but kept returning to his Discworld.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Matt, thanks for the comments, I think that’s what I have in mind for myself, it’s like something is calling out to me to just continue doing what I’ve always done!


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s